Marion · Prospect · Caledonia · Bucyrus - built for Marion County homes Talk through a project: (740) 736-3805
Marion Cabinet Co. - engraved brass plate on quarter-sawn oak Marion Cabinet Co.

Guides · 2026-10-15

A built-in buffet for the dining room of an older Marion house

Houses of the foursquare era were often built with a buffet or a pair of china cabinets in the dining room. Plenty of Marion dining rooms have since lost theirs to a remodel, and some never had one. Putting one back comes down to four decisions, and they go in order: which wall, what the counter is for, what the drawers hold, and what sits above. The last section is for the house that had a buffet once and wants to know what happened to it.

What is a built-in buffet for, if the table is right there?

A built-in buffet is a serving counter an arm’s reach from the table with storage underneath for the things only the dining room uses. It also gives a long blank wall something to do. Of all the custom built-ins a house can have, it is the one that belongs to a single room, built into its wall and finished like the room’s own woodwork.

The table is where people eat. The buffet is where food waits, the carved roast during dinner and the coffee once the plates are cleared. Without one, those things crowd the table or go back to the kitchen.

A sideboard from a furniture store covers some of that. It comes in a standard length, though, so it ends up a little short of the wall or sitting out past the baseboard with a dust gap behind it. Storage is the other half of the job. Tablecloths, the good flatware, serving platters and the gravy boat that comes out twice a year all need a home, and in most houses that home is a kitchen cabinet needed for something else.

Which dining room wall can take one?

Usually the wall with no doorway in it. A buffet needs an unbroken stretch of wall and room in front for someone to stand and serve, which rules out the walls carrying the kitchen door, the hall opening or a cased opening to the living room. What remains is often one blank wall, or the wall with the window.

The blank wall is the plain case. The buffet runs most of its length, centered, with some wall left at each end so it doesn’t jam into the corners.

The window wall is the older arrangement and often the handsomer one. A china cabinet stands on each side of the window and the counter runs between them under the sill, so the window becomes the center of the piece. Whether that works depends on how low the window comes down. A low sill can mean the cabinets flank the window and the space beneath it stays open.

A shallow wall, where the table sits close and the chairs back up toward it, can still take something narrow: a serving ledge over a bank of drawers, more shelf than cabinet.

If the wall you have in mind is the one shared with the kitchen, settle first whether it is staying, which is the question in our guide to taking out the kitchen wall.

How deep and how high should the counter be?

The room sets the depth. Pull the chairs out the way people sit in them, then see how much floor is left between the chair backs and the wall. The buffet can take what remains once someone can still walk behind a seated guest. Height follows the sill of a nearby window if there is one, and otherwise a comfortable height for serving.

Clearance matters most. A buffet that eats into the walkway gets bumped every time someone stands up, and a chair pushed back from the table should never catch a drawer pull. In a narrow dining room that can mean a shallower base than anyone would pick in a showroom, with drawers built to work at that depth.

Height has more to do with serving than people expect. A counter someone serves from wants to sit clear of the chair backs, so a platter set down behind a guest doesn’t brush a shoulder, but low enough to carve or ladle at without reaching. Under a window, the top usually sits a little lower than the sill so the window trim stays whole.

The top is a decision of its own. A wood top matches the room and can take a mark from a hot dish. Stone, or wood under a hard finish, handles a warming tray better.

What should the drawers hold?

Drawers in a dining room should be sized for flat things. Kitchen-depth drawers end up packed with folded tablecloths and stacked platters, and the one you want is always at the bottom. Planning the drawers around what goes in them sorts that out.

  • Wide, shallow drawers for tablecloths and runners, so they lie flat or folded once and don’t come out creased into squares.
  • A lined drawer for the good flatware, with a divided tray so the pieces don’t knock together.
  • Vertical dividers in one base cabinet for platters, trays and boards, standing on edge so one slides out without lifting the rest.
  • One deep drawer for candles, napkin rings and the serving pieces a holiday needs once a year.

Doors below suit the tall things, a punch bowl or a big pitcher. Many buffets end up with drawers in the middle and a door cabinet at each end.

Should the upper cases have glass, solid doors or no doors at all?

Glass doors suit the dishes worth seeing, and they keep the dust off them. Open shelves suit whatever gets used every week. Solid doors cover everything else. Most dining rooms land on two of those, often glass in the china cabinets above with solid doors lower down or at the ends.

Glass uppers look their best lit from inside. A small light at the top of each case, with glass shelves so it reaches the bottom, makes the dishes what you see from the table in the evening.

Open shelves suit a household that uses the good dishes and doesn’t want to open a door to reach them. They also collect dust faster.

Two things are easiest to plan while the wall is open. One is the wiring for those lights. The other is an outlet in the backsplash above the counter for a coffee maker or a warming tray. Both are the electrician’s work, and both cost far less to run before the back of the buffet goes on.

What if the house had a buffet and it is gone?

A dining room that lost its buffet usually still shows where it stood. Look for a patched strip of floor along one wall, a gap or a newer piece in the baseboard, or a painted-over outline on the plaster where the case once covered it. Those marks give you the wall and the width, and sometimes the height the original reached.

Sometimes the original is still there with drawers that stick or bottoms that have split. Old drawer runners wear grooves into the sides over a century of use, and a piece in that state is often worth repairing rather than replacing. The drawers can usually be rebuilt without touching the case or its finish.

A new buffet in a room with original woodwork has to match it to look like it belongs, and our guide to built-in bookshelves that look original covers how that matching is done.

A buffet on its own prices as a single built-in, typically $1,800-$5,000 built and installed. A buffet with a china cabinet on each side of a window is a built-in wall, usually $5,000-$15,000 depending on width, doors and lighting. The cost page lays out what a built-in costs next to the rest of the work we price.

Rather put the question to a person?

Call and describe your room - you'll get the same straight answer, tuned to your actual house.

Request an estimate

Describe the room. Get a real number, in writing.

A few sentences is plenty - which room, roughly how big, painted or stained, and when you hope to have it done. You hear back from a cabinetmaker, not a call center, and the estimate arrives in writing. Prefer to start out loud? (740) 736-3805.

  • The number comes in writing before anything is scheduled - materials and labor together
  • Measured from your actual walls, floors, and ceilings - not a catalog's standard boxes
  • One Marion-area point of contact from the first measure to the last hinge adjustment

Call (740) 736-3805 - written estimate first